A recent federal court ruling has sent ripples through the estate planning and business law communities, potentially changing how buy-sell agreements in estate plans are interpreted and enforced. This development underscores the critical importance of regularly reviewing and updating these agreements to ensure they align with both legal standards and estate planning goals.
Background on Buy-Sell Agreements
Buy-sell agreements are legal contracts commonly used by business co-owners to plan for the future transfer of business interests. They dictate what happens to an owner’s share of the business upon death, disability, retirement, or exit from the company. When properly integrated, buy-sell agreements in estate plans can ensure smooth transitions, prevent disputes, and provide liquidity to heirs.
The Court’s Decision
In the recent case of Estate of Connelly v. United States, the court examined how the valuation of a buy-sell agreement affects estate tax liability. The case involved a closely held corporation that had a buy-sell agreement funded by life insurance. Upon one owner’s death, the agreement stipulated that the remaining owner would purchase the deceased’s shares at a fixed price. However, the IRS argued — and the court agreed — that the value of the business for estate tax purposes should include the death benefit proceeds from the life insurance policy.
This means that even if a buy-sell agreement sets a fixed price for shares, the IRS may not accept that value if it doesn’t reflect fair market value. As a result, the estate may face a higher tax bill than expected.
Implications for Estate Planning
This ruling has significant implications for buy-sell agreements in estate plans, particularly when life insurance is used to fund the purchase of business interests. Business owners and estate planners should:
- Review and update agreements to ensure they reflect fair market value and are consistent with IRS requirements.
- Avoid fixed-price terms unless they are regularly updated based on a current, independent appraisal.
- Coordinate funding mechanisms, such as life insurance, with the overall estate plan to avoid unintended tax consequences.
Moving Forward
Given the complexities introduced by this decision, it’s more important than ever for business owners to consult with both legal and tax professionals. Those with buy-sell agreements in estate plans should revisit these documents as part of a broader review of estate planning strategies. By doing so, they can mitigate risk, ensure compliance with current law, and protect their legacy for future generations.
The Ray Group’s Wealth Management team may also be able to find opportunities to support you. Contact us with your questions. We can point you in the right direction to get a thorough review or funding of your buy-sell agreement.
You may also enjoy reading: Understanding Crypto Tax Rules
